Illinois ' Attorney General Lisa Madigan is the latest consumer advocate to warn the public that refund anticipation loans are a bad deal. Madigan told Illinoisans Tuesday that consumers should not mistake these loans for advances on tax refunds. The high-cost short-term loans typically come packaged with attached fees for tax preparation, tax filing, electronic filing, and even check cashing. RALs previously have been identified as predatory by numerous consumer advocates including the National Consumer Law Center and the Consumer Federation of America.
What is the alternative for taxpayers who say "no" to RALs? Consumer advocates say it's filing a return electronically and getting a tax refund direct deposited from the IRS in as little as 10 days. Some states issue their tax refunds even more quickly.
Changes in the RAL Market
Smart Money looked at the RAL market last month after federal regulators knocked one of the big players- H&R Block- out of the game. The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency ordered H&R Block's banking partner HSBC to cease issuing RALs. Tax preparer Jackson Hewitt is set to assume the lead as the primary RAL issuer as federal tax season goes into full swing.
With the removal of HSBC from the RAL market, Jackson Hewitt's lender Republic BankCorp. Inc is now the only major player left. The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation warned Republic earlier this month that its RAL practices were "unsafe and unsound," a warning that came to light when the bank made a required disclosure to the Securities and Exchange Commission.
The Advantages and Disadvantages of RALs
The advantages of RALs are legion- for the bank issuing them. The disadvantages are equally legion for consumers who at best obtain some of their tax refund a few weeks early at an excessive cost. Consider:
* Republic's $61.22 fee for a $1500 loan is the equivalent of 149 percent Annual Percentage Rate interest.
* Banks issuing RALs took $600 million from 7.2 million taxpayer refunds in 2009 (a decrease from 2008 when they took $738 million from 8.4 million taxpayers.)
* Not only is the charge for RAL issuance typically excessive, it is paid upfront before the remainder of the refund is released to the taxpayer. Wisconsin 's Dept. of Revenue warns that state's consumers that if the tax refund falls short of the expected amount, the consumer is on the hook for the balance of the loan.
* Banks may cite checking account costs as reasons a consumer should agree to an RAL rather than simply open an account and have a tax refund direct deposited. However, government agencies say that free bank accounts are widely available. Simply typing "free checking no minimum balance account" into a search engine will turn up a variety of potential free bank account options.
The Internal Revenue Service is considering a ban on RALs. But unsurprisingly, the IRS's concern is not abuse of taxpayers by predatory lenders. Instead, the IRS is concerned that the potential for receiving an RAL may encourage fraud, either by the taxpayer himself or unscrupulous tax preparers.
Carol Bengle Gilbert writes about consumer issues for the Yahoo! Contributor Network.
Browse your computer here